There’s nothing quite like the feel of a brand-new leather holster — the smell of fresh leather, the perfect stitching, the rugged look. But if you’ve just pulled your new holster out of the box and find it a little too snug, don’t worry — that's exactly how it should be.
Breaking in a leather holster is part of the journey, but if you rush it or do it wrong, you can easily ruin a piece that should last you decades. Let’s walk through how to properly break in a new leather holster without damaging it.
Why Are New Leather Holsters So Tight?
High-quality leather holsters — like the ones we craft here at Black Swamp Leather Company LLC — are purposely made tight. Leather is a natural material; it stretches and molds over time. A snug fit ensures that, after break-in, your firearm will sit securely and draw smoothly without being loose or sloppy.
If a holster is too loose out of the box, it will only get looser with use — and that’s a problem you don’t want.
What NOT to Do
Before we dig into the right way, here are a few things you should never do:
-
Don’t soak your holster in water. Water softens leather fibers too much and can warp the shape.
-
Don’t over-oil or grease it. Leather needs to breathe; saturating it with oils or chemicals can weaken and rot it over time.
-
Don’t shove oversized objects into it. Stretching it too aggressively can permanently deform the holster.
-
Don’t leave it in a hot car or use a heat gun. Heat can dry out and crack the leather.
A little patience goes a long way.
Step-by-Step: How to Break In Your Leather Holster the Right Way
1. Insert Your Unloaded Firearm Carefully
Start by inserting your unloaded firearm into the holster slowly and steadily. You might feel resistance — that's normal. Press firmly but don’t force it. Let the leather naturally stretch a bit.
If it won't go in easily even with firm pressure, move to Step 2.
2. Wrap the Firearm (Optional)
If the fit is extremely tight, a simple trick can help:
-
Wrap your unloaded firearm in a single layer of wax paper or a gallon-sized plastic bag (like a freezer bag).
-
Insert the wrapped gun into the holster.
-
Let it sit overnight.
The slight extra thickness will gently stretch the leather without forcing it.
3. Draw and Reholster Repeatedly
After the overnight stretch, remove the bag and try inserting and drawing the gun multiple times.
Each time you reholster and draw, the leather fibers flex and adjust, slowly molding themselves to your specific firearm.
Try about 50-100 repetitions over the course of a day or two. You don’t have to rush through it — steady, repeated motion is the key.
4. Practice a Firm Grip
When holstering, always drive the firearm straight down into the holster using a solid grip.
Don't "wiggle" it side to side; leather will stretch wherever you force it, and wiggling can cause uneven wear.
5. Check Retention
After a few days of normal practice, check the retention by turning the holster upside down (with the unloaded firearm inside).
A good holster should retain the gun even when inverted, though it shouldn’t take excessive force to draw it.
If it still feels too tight after this process, repeat Step 2 one more time — but never jump ahead to more aggressive measures.
A Word on Leather Conditioners
For holsters, conditioners should be used sparingly, if at all.
Some makers recommend a very light coat of a beeswax-based leather conditioner if your holster feels dry — but for most cases, the natural oils from your hands and everyday use are enough to keep it supple.
When in doubt, less is more.
Final Thoughts
Breaking in a leather holster is a ritual as old as concealed carry itself.
It takes a little time and patience, but doing it right ensures your holster will form a perfect bond with your firearm — offering years of dependable service without sacrificing safety or style.
Remember: a tight holster isn’t a problem — it’s a sign of quality.
Take your time, treat it right, and your leather will reward you with a lifetime of loyal performance.
Leave a comment